Les Victoires de la Musique. It'll have explained. Mid-November 2010, the list of artists "appointment" at the Victoires 2011 (including the ceremony should take place in early March at the Palais des Congres de Paris) is sent to people in the art, artists, producers, editors, art directors, radio programmers, turners, journalists introduced ... College of a thousand voters. This booklet, by category (female artist of the year, male artist, revelations, album rock / rap / world music, etc..) zheureux zélecteurs the need to make a name, and only one! Hello eclecticism. The three contenders will compete in the most cited trophy. Three. Not one more. To hell with sectarianism.
(Click the image to zoom)
They are 39 to be part of the top three and win a victory. Thirty-nine singers, some of which were already present in previous years, with more or less the same product, ie its substitute: a live disc .
The question should be asked, but does not arise seems to be: an album consisting of unreleased songs, can be compared and compete with a record audience of old songs? A fortiori, the recording of the concert of an artist can have any ambition when his newest original disc was nominated at a previous edition? Although Vanessa Paradis has won the Victory 2008 through DIVINYDILLE she competed again this year with ONE NIGHT AT VERSAILLES , capturing an acoustic show born in the wake of DIVINYDILLE ! Power majors to put their all costs Featured at the expense of original creations on the one hand and diversity on the other. Discerned: Heart of the Pirates, who do not have a new album, is found in the list of possible contenders when she was already nominated in 2010. Diam's is also the incarnation of a scenic CD released in October 2009 ( SOS) and curiously forgotten in March 2010. Same for Arielle Dombasle, while retaining GLAMOUR TO DEATH was released in April 2009. Regarding Ariane Moffatt, still in the race this year, she was already nominated in 2010, Class Revelation while (excellent) ALL MEANING was released in April 2008 ... Not to mention the discs "registered" before they are in the business! ONE NIGHT AT VERSAILLES Vanessa Paradis and BLUE SUN Sylvie Vartan, for example, published November 29! How to vote for a disk that is not released? As for the CD Line Renaud ( STREET WASHINGTO N), it has appeared that November 8, 2010, hours before the mailing of ballots ... Way to impose voting, and by extension the public , productions deemed "important"? In its edition of November 19, Figaro announced that Warner hoped to sell 70,000 units of WASHINGTON STREET presented as an event. It's bad start. Despite the hype, there it is up less than 6,000 copies (3,829 ex. + 2033) in two weeks of operation ...
It would be much easier and fairer to compete artists who have released an album of new songs during the twelve months preceding the ceremony.
For 2010, the case ultimately would be resolved between 3 or 4 of these ladies: Joan Cherhal (for CHARADE ), Françoise Hardy ( WITHOUT RAIN BY APLUIE) , Claire Diterzi ( ROSA THE RED ), Souad Massi ( HOURIA O), Zazie ( 7) - is still nominated as Zazie !..., and Lynda Lemay ( INJURED ). There would be outstanding and the show.
Side boys, they are not thirty-nine, but eighty-four (84!) To compete for a seat at the Palais des Congres, in a jumble of musical styles, of repetition " live" and absurdities of artistic (Dany Brilliant, Patrick Fiori, Gilbert Montagne, Michel Sardou ...), although there are notable discs Erik Arnaud ( WEAVE , his third studio album) Bertrand Belin ( HYPERNUIT , his third), Louis Ronan Choisy (FEATHER RIVER , his fourth), Louis Bertrand (L E E COMMERCIAL CENTR , his fourth) and Florent Marchetti ( COURCHEVEL , his third) that are anything but beginners, but playing under the colors of a small label ... The Victoires de la Musique, I smell the mess.
Baptist Vignol
(Click the image to zoom) They are 39 to be part of the top three and win a victory. Thirty-nine singers, some of which were already present in previous years, with more or less the same product, ie its substitute: a live disc .
The question should be asked, but does not arise seems to be: an album consisting of unreleased songs, can be compared and compete with a record audience of old songs? A fortiori, the recording of the concert of an artist can have any ambition when his newest original disc was nominated at a previous edition? Although Vanessa Paradis has won the Victory 2008 through DIVINYDILLE she competed again this year with ONE NIGHT AT VERSAILLES , capturing an acoustic show born in the wake of DIVINYDILLE ! Power majors to put their all costs Featured at the expense of original creations on the one hand and diversity on the other. Discerned: Heart of the Pirates, who do not have a new album, is found in the list of possible contenders when she was already nominated in 2010. Diam's is also the incarnation of a scenic CD released in October 2009 ( SOS) and curiously forgotten in March 2010. Same for Arielle Dombasle, while retaining GLAMOUR TO DEATH was released in April 2009. Regarding Ariane Moffatt, still in the race this year, she was already nominated in 2010, Class Revelation while (excellent) ALL MEANING was released in April 2008 ... Not to mention the discs "registered" before they are in the business! ONE NIGHT AT VERSAILLES Vanessa Paradis and BLUE SUN Sylvie Vartan, for example, published November 29! How to vote for a disk that is not released? As for the CD Line Renaud ( STREET WASHINGTO N), it has appeared that November 8, 2010, hours before the mailing of ballots ... Way to impose voting, and by extension the public , productions deemed "important"? In its edition of November 19, Figaro announced that Warner hoped to sell 70,000 units of WASHINGTON STREET presented as an event. It's bad start. Despite the hype, there it is up less than 6,000 copies (3,829 ex. + 2033) in two weeks of operation ...
It would be much easier and fairer to compete artists who have released an album of new songs during the twelve months preceding the ceremony.
For 2010, the case ultimately would be resolved between 3 or 4 of these ladies: Joan Cherhal (for CHARADE ), Françoise Hardy ( WITHOUT RAIN BY APLUIE) , Claire Diterzi ( ROSA THE RED ), Souad Massi ( HOURIA O), Zazie ( 7) - is still nominated as Zazie !..., and Lynda Lemay ( INJURED ). There would be outstanding and the show.
Side boys, they are not thirty-nine, but eighty-four (84!) To compete for a seat at the Palais des Congres, in a jumble of musical styles, of repetition " live" and absurdities of artistic (Dany Brilliant, Patrick Fiori, Gilbert Montagne, Michel Sardou ...), although there are notable discs Erik Arnaud ( WEAVE , his third studio album) Bertrand Belin ( HYPERNUIT , his third), Louis Ronan Choisy (FEATHER RIVER , his fourth), Louis Bertrand (L E E COMMERCIAL CENTR , his fourth) and Florent Marchetti ( COURCHEVEL , his third) that are anything but beginners, but playing under the colors of a small label ... The Victoires de la Musique, I smell the mess.
Baptist Vignol
0 comments:
Post a Comment